Subject: Letter of Advice – Conflict of Interest and Directors’ Duties Under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Dear Mr. Russo,
I write to advise you on the potential legal implications of your indirect and direct interests in a company tendering for a contract with Creamy Cake Ltd, the company of which you are a non-executive director. This advice covers:
- Whether your conduct constitutes a breach of any provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
- Whether there is a duty to disclose your interests.
- Whether you may lawfully participate in the upcoming board meeting.
Finding research tasks difficult? Explore free, top-quality assignment drafts from the Best Assignment Writing Service Australia.
1. Identification of Relevant Legal Issues
The legal question presented by factual scenario that is presented by Mr. Angelo Russo, a non-executive director of Creamy Cake Ltd, concerns several critical issues under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Mr. It has been disclosed by Russo that one of the companies who have registered a tender to provide a new cake machine to Creamy Cake Ltd is owned by his friend, Mr. Farabuto Smith. He has further revealed that he holds 30 percent share in the same company. Such facts show there is a personal monetary interest in an issue which directly concerns the affairs of the company in which he is a board member.
The main legal questions that come up as a result of this scenario are whether Mr. Russo has violated his statutory obligation as a director under the Corporations Act. In particular, it should be established whether he has failed to exercise his duty of care and diligence as provided in section 180(1), whether he has failed to act in good faith in the best interest of the corporation as in section 181(1) and whether he has failed to act in the best interest of the corporation by acting improperly as in section 182(1). The other key question is whether he has not disclosed a material personal interest as stipulated in section 191 of the Act. Besides, the legality of his involvement in the next board meeting should be evaluated against the limitations stated in section 195. Lastly, the violations of these provisions can result in civil or criminal liability in sections 184 and 1317E.
2. Statement of Law
2.1 Duty of Care and Diligence – Section 180(1)
The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) imposes on directors a duty, under section 180(1) to exercise their powers and perform their duties with a level of care and diligence that a reasonable person, acting in the position and in the same circumstances, would exercise. This is an objective criterio,n and courts determine whether or not the director is complying by evaluating their behaviour against that of a reasonable person in the same office.
In ASIC v Healey (2011) 196 FCR 291, or the Centro case, the Federal Court concluded that directors, and non-executive directors in particular, should assume an active role in learning about company operations, and be able to detect risks. Any action not to ask or to reveal, to disclose, conflicts of interest, might be a violation of this duty. Directors should not be just bystanders but are supposed to object proposals when the need arises so as to safeguard the interests of the company.
2.2 Duty to Act in Good Faith – Section 181(1)
According to section 181(1) of the Act a director should be acting in good faith in the best interest of the corporation and proper purpose. This is a codification of the fair fiduciary duty of good faith and prevents the practice of directors serving their own best interests in the company.
An example of the failure to respect this duty can be seen in the case of ASIC v Adler (2002) 168 FLR 253, in which a director made his company invest in an entity in which he had a personal interest, and in which the director failed to disclose all of the facts of this interest. The court concluded that the director did not serve the best interests of the company but instead he used his office to serve another related party. This principle clarifies that a director with a personal interest in a company transaction should not be allowed to be involved in the decision-making process unless the personal interest is entirely disclosed and such disclosure is duly addressed.
2.3 Duty Not to Improperly Use Position – Section 182(1)
Section 182(1) states that a director should not abuse his or her office to acquire an edge to himself or a third party or to bring injury to the corporation. Improperly can be described as the act of applying one's position in a manner that does not conform to the responsibilities and expectations of that position.
In R v Byrnes (1995) 183 CLR 501, the High Court stated that misuse of a directorial position may also arise in the situation when the gain that is received is indirect. One of the most obvious violations of this section could be the improper exercise of influence in decision-making, in situations where the director is financially interested in the outcome. The law does not care just about actual misconduct, but the appearance of impropriety which can damage the citizens confidence in corporate governance.
2.4 Disclosure of Material Personal Interest – Section 191
Under the Act, section 191(1) constitutes a statutory obligation on the directors to disclose any material personal interest in anything that pertains to the affairs of the company. The material concept is used in a broad way and is encompassed by any interest that may reasonably be likely to affect the decision of the director. The disclosure is to be made to the other directors as soon as possible as well as should contain the nature and the extent of the interest.
This was considered in Sanford v Sanford Courier Service Pty Ltd [1986] VR 327 where the court pointed out that directors should not hide that they have personal interests in business transactions of a company. The question of disclosure is such that it may or may not happen at the actual time the vote is taken by the director. This provision is intended to bring about transparency and avoid making decisions that are likely to be clouded by selfish interest. It will also be necessary to disclose in the meeting minutes and place in the company register of interests, as required by section 191(3).

2.5 Restrictions on Voting – Section 195
Section 195(1) states that a director of a public company who has a material personal interest in a particular matter that the board may be discussing should not be present at the time of the discussion or vote on the matter. This is an absolute provision except where ASIC has permission or where the other non-interested directors have passed a resolution that the interested director may participate, and such a directive is authorised by the constitution of the company.
This was dictated in Fitzsimmons v R [1997] FCA 1128, where the court decided that attendance at a board meeting where a matter in which the director had a personal interest was in itself a breach. Such a provision aims to prevent the possibility of influence on corporate decisions and the feeling of bias. In the case of public companies, adherence to this part is particularly significant in ensuring that there is integrity in the governance processes.
2.6 Criminal and Civil Liability – Sections 184 and 1317E
Section 184 criminal liability arises in the case of a director who is recklessly or dishonestly in breach of the duties in sections 180, 181 or 182. In particular, the director can be subjected to criminal charges in case he/she is discovered to have used his/her position dishonestly to achieve a personal benefit. The penalties may include hefty fines and even imprisonment, and disqualification from running corporations.
Section 1317E allows ASIC to take civil actions against the breach of the duties of directors. Pecuniary penalties, compensation orders and disqualification orders are civil consequences. In the case of ASIC vs Vines [2005] NSWSC 738, civil penalties were imposed on directors who failed to perform their legal duties, regardless of whether they were non-executive directors. The case proved that insufficient direct participation is not used as an excuse of violation of statutory obligations.
3. Application of Law to Facts
3.1 Conflict of Interest and Use of Position
It is a conflict of interest that Mr. Russo has a considerable financial interest in one of the bidding companies. In general law and in the statutory criteria of sections 181 and 182, the directors are not permitted to act in such a manner that they cause self benefit or benefit to other people at the expense of the best interests of the company. The direct potential of personal gain is fixed by the 30 percent ownership in a tendering company, especially when the contract goes to the firm. Although Mr. Russo might feel that the tender Mr. Smith company has offered is better on merit, he is not in the right position to assess the issue objectively because of his personal interest.
In case Mr. Russo tries to influence the board's decision or participates in discussions without disclosing his interest, he may be regarded as abusing his position and violating Section 182. To this end, the emergence of a dispute in itself may suffice to erode confidence and subject both Mr. Russo and the company to regulatory scrutiny. His acts can also be against the responsibility to act in good faith as stipulated in section 181, since promoting individual or friendliness on behalf of the company overrides the fundamental fiduciary responsibility of loyalty.
3.2 Duty to Disclose – s191 Breach Analysis
The disclosure of Mr. Russo is also of a questionable nature in terms of the timing and sufficiency. Section 191 is where a director must reveal any material personal interest in an issue concerning the affairs of the company as soon as possible. The fact that Mr. Russo did not make disclosure of his friendship with Mr. Smith, only, but disclosure of his shareholding in the tendering company of 30 per cent, indicates partial disclosure or late disclosure. This omission is material as it deprives the board of the essential information upon which to determine whether bias or undue influence exists.
The interest is personal and material. A 30 percent ownership in a foreign firm would be a substantial monetary investment and it would offer a genuine possibility of direct gain. Thus it is not far out of the range of the meaning of material personal interest under section 191. The subsequent disclosure of his shareholding does not remedy the breach by Mr. Russo who did not disclose it as and when it was due. The court in Sanford v Sanford Courier Service Pty Ltd [1986] VR 327 upheld that the nature of interests of directors in corporate transactions is not to be postponed or hidden. Mr. The inability to reveal this information by Russo in a timely and transparent manner is an evident violation of section 191.
3.3 Participation in the Board Meeting
The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) clearly outlines section 195, of which the directors of public companies are forbidden to attend or participate in any meeting where they have a substantial personal interest in the issue at hand. Creamy Cake Ltd has been defined as a large publicly listed company, which implies that it fits perfectly into the definition of a public company. Hence, Mr. Russo may not be involved in any discussion and vote on the choice of the tender.
It is not even indicated that ASIC approval has been requested, nor that the constitution of the company can authorize the directors to resolve to permit the participation of interested directors in such a resolution. Without these exceptions Mr. Russo should not attend or vote at the meeting. If he does this, it would amount to a direct contravention of section 195. A decision reached at such a meeting would be open to a challenge on grounds of procedural irregularity and it would cast Mr. Russo and possibly the board as a whole into the risks of reputational and legal harm.
Fitzsimmons v R [1997] FCA 1128 was decided to the effect that passive attendance at such deliberations, where the director does not actually vote, could be a breach where the attendance of the director is relevant to the decision-making process. Using this principle, Mr. Russo ought to act to formally recuse himself during the board meeting and make sure that the absence is captured in the minutes so as to show that he is acting within the statutory requirements.
Students exploring commercial contracts and corporate governance regulations can also refer to Business Law Assignment Help for subject-related academic guidance.
4. Recommendations
Mr. Russo has to provide a written disclosure to the board of Creamy Cake Ltd and state the nature and the extent of his 30 per cent ownership in the tendering company. This disclosure should be captured in the minutes of the meeting and in the company register of interest, as required by section 191(3) of the Corporations Act 2001 ( Cth). Postponed or incomplete disclosure is inadequate and can amount to a breach. Mr. Russo should recuse himself in regard to all the meetings, discussions and decisions concerning the tender as mentioned in section 195. His attendance at these meetings can nullify the process and lead the board to a legal risk. The recusal should be properly recorded in the board minutes so as to provide transparency and procedural adherence.
In case of doubts in the application to section 195, Creamy Cake Ltd can also seek advice or approval of ASIC under section 196. Although not mandatory, ASIC approval could be used to strengthen the integrity of the governance processes, especially in a publicly listed company. Lastly, Mr. Russo will be required to undergo a corporate governance refresher training, especially the conflict-of-interest requirement and directors' duties.
5. Conclusion
This is an such material personal interest that it should be disclosed in accordance with Section 191 since Mr. Russo is the owner of a tendering company (material personal interest) and being a 30 percent ownership interest holder. Involvement in the identical type of decision-making again can also result in the violation of the provisions of 180, 181, 182 and 195 of the Australian Corporations Act 2001. Such violations can be associated with civil and, in case of dishonesty, proved, criminal liability. To reduce the legal and reputational risks, Mr. Russo has to report the interest, resign all his board actions in the issue, and consider additional compliance assistance. The stated measures will serve to make sure that the tender process at Creamy Cake Ltd can be viewed as transparent, legal, and beyond criticism.
Yours sincerely,
References
- Arden, Lady, ‘In Whose Interests Should Companies Be Run?’ [2025] King s Law Journal 1
- Banerjee, Anup, Mattias Nordqvist and Karin Hellerstedt, ‘The Role of the Board Chair—a Literature Review and Suggestions for Future Research’ (2020) 28(6) Corporate Governance: An International Review 372
- Langford, Rosemary Teele and Ian Ramsay, ‘Does Section 191 of the Corporations Act Include Conflicting Duties?’ [2018] SSRN Electronic Journal
- Wan, Wai Yee, ‘Directors’ Defence of Reliance on Professional Advisers under Anglo-Australian Law’ (2018) 44(1) Common Law World Review 71
- Watson, Susan and Lynn Buckley, ‘Directors’ Positive Duty to Act in the Interests of the Entity: Shareholders’ Interests Bounded by Corporate Purpose’ (2024) 24(1) The journal of corporate law studies/Journal of corporate law studies 1
- ASIC, The Replaceable Rules for Company Governance | ASIC (2025) Asic.gov.au <https://www.asic.gov.au/for-business-and-companies/companies/register-a-company/the-replaceable-rules-for-company-governance/>
- ATO, Legal Database - View: Principal Legislation: SECTION 180 (2022) Ato.gov.au <https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/print?DocID=PAC%2F20010050%2F180&PiT=99991231235958>
- Australian Parliament, An Empirical Analysis of Public Enforcement of Directors’ (2024) <https://www.aph.gov.au/DocumentStore.ashx?id=23a55e8f-6b93-4ab1-a4b0-8e74a70d803d>
- Commonwealth Consolidated Acts, CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 - SECT 184 Good Faith, Use of Position and Use of Information--Criminal Offences (2018) www5.austlii.edu.au <https://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/cth/consol_act/ca2001172/s184.html>
- Korbel, Chris, Duty to Disclose Material Personal Interest | Corporations Act (24 June 2022) Potts Lawyers <https://pottslawyers.com.au/blog/2022/06/24/duty-to-disclose-personal-interest/>
- Queensland Government, 7.3 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) (2018) qld.gov.au <https://www.premiers.qld.gov.au/publications/categories/policies-and-codes/handbooks/welcome-aboard/member-duties/corp-act-2001-c.aspx>
- Solo, Alex, Understanding Section 191 of the Corporations Act for Australian Businesses (16 June 2025) Sprintlaw <https://sprintlaw.com.au/articles/understanding-section-191-of-the-corporations-act-for-australian-businesses/>
- Treasury, Corporations Act 2001 (2022) www.legislation.gov.au <https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/C2022C00215>
- Case law
- ASIC v Healey & Ors [2011] FCA 717
- Securities and Investments Commission v Adler (2002) 168 FLR 253; 41 ACSR 72 at [410]
- R v Byrnes - [1995] HCA 1 - 183 CLR 501; 69 ALJR 710
- Sanford v Sanford Courier Service Pty Ltd [1986] VR 327
- Fitzsimmons v R (1997) 15 ACLC 666, 668.
- ASIC v Vines (2005) 23 ACLC 1387; NSWSC 738
- Queensland Government, 7.3 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) (2018) qld.gov.au <https://www.premiers.qld.gov.au/publications/categories/policies-and-codes/handbooks/welcome-aboard/member-duties/corp-act-2001-c.aspx>.
- Queensland Government, 7.3 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) (2018) qld.gov.au <https://www.premiers.qld.gov.au/publications/categories/policies-and-codes/handbooks/welcome-aboard/member-duties/corp-act-2001-c.aspx>.
- Wai Yee Wan, ‘Directors’ Defence of Reliance on Professional Advisers under Anglo-Australian Law’ (2018) 44(1) Common Law World Review 71.
- Anup Banerjee, Mattias Nordqvist and Karin Hellerstedt, ‘The Role of the Board Chair—a Literature Review and Suggestions for Future Research’ (2020) 28(6) Corporate Governance: An International Review 372.
- ATO, Legal Database - View: Principal Legislation: SECTION 180 (2022) Ato.gov.au <https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/print?DocID=PAC%2F20010050%2F180&PiT=99991231235958>.
- ASIC v Healey & Ors [2011] FCA 717
- Securities and Investments Commission v Adler (2002) 168 FLR 253; 41 ACSR 72 at [410]
- Lady Arden, ‘In Whose Interests Should Companies Be Run?’ [2025] King s Law Journal 1.
- Queensland Government, 7.3 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) (2018) qld.gov.au <https://www.premiers.qld.gov.au/publications/categories/policies-and-codes/handbooks/welcome-aboard/member-duties/corp-act-2001-c.aspx>.
- R v Byrnes - [1995] HCA 1 - 183 CLR 501; 69 ALJR 710
- Susan Watson and Lynn Buckley, ‘Directors’ Positive Duty to Act in the Interests of the Entity: Shareholders’ Interests Bounded by Corporate Purpose’ (2024) 24(1) The journal of corporate law studies/Journal of corporate law studies 1.
- Sanford v Sanford Courier Service Pty Ltd [1986] VR 327
- ATO, Legal Database - View: Principal Legislation: SECTION 180 (2022) Ato.gov.au <https://www.ato.gov.au/law/view/print?DocID=PAC%2F20010050%2F180&PiT=99991231235958>.
- Fitzsimmons v R (1997) 15 ACLC 666, 668.
- Commonwealth Consolidated Acts, CORPORATIONS ACT 2001 - SECT 184 Good Faith, Use of Position and Use of Information--Criminal Offences (2018) www5.austlii.edu.au <https://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/cth/consol_act/ca2001172/s184.html>.
- ASIC v Vines (2005) 23 ACLC 1387; NSWSC 738
- Australian Parliament, An Empirical Analysis of Public Enforcement of Directors’ (2024) <https://www.aph.gov.au/DocumentStore.ashx?id=23a55e8f-6b93-4ab1-a4b0-8e74a70d803d>.
- Rosemary Teele Langford and Ian Ramsay, ‘Does Section 191 of the Corporations Act Include Conflicting Duties?’ [2018] SSRN Electronic Journal.
- Sanford v Sanford Courier Service Pty Ltd [1986] VR 327
- ASIC, The Replaceable Rules for Company Governance | ASIC (2025) Asic.gov.au <https://www.asic.gov.au/for-business-and-companies/companies/register-a-company/the-replaceable-rules-for-company-governance/>.
- Chris Korbel, Duty to Disclose Material Personal Interest | Corporations Act (24 June 2022) Potts Lawyers <https://pottslawyers.com.au/blog/2022/06/24/duty-to-disclose-personal-interest/>.
- Fitzsimmons v R (1997) 15 ACLC 666, 668.
- Alex Solo, Understanding Section 191 of the Corporations Act for Australian Businesses (16 June 2025) Sprintlaw <https://sprintlaw.com.au/articles/understanding-section-191-of-the-corporations-act-for-australian-businesses/>.
- Treasury, Corporations Act 2001 (2022) www.legislation.gov.au <https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/C2022C00215>.